The Dirty Cheesecake
AKA Made by Lili's
A family-owned dessert destination specializing in handcrafted cheesecakes, cupcakes, cannoli, cookies, and our famous banana pudding — home of the iconic Cheesecake on a Stick
About The Dirty Cheesecake
At The Dirty Cheesecake, dessert isn't just something sweet — it's an experience. As a family-owned dessert destination, we take pride in creating handcrafted treats that keep people coming back for more. From our rich, creamy cheesecakes and freshly baked cupcakes to our cannoli, cookies, and famous banana pudding, every dessert is made fresh daily in small batches using premium ingredients.
We're best known for our iconic Cheesecake on a Stick — a handheld indulgence that has quickly become a customer favorite and a viral sensation. Each piece is dipped, drizzled, and crafted to deliver the perfect balance of flavor, texture, and pure dessert satisfaction.
Whether you're stopping in for a late-night sweet fix, celebrating a special occasion, or ordering desserts for a large event, The Dirty Cheesecake is where unforgettable desserts are made.
What We're Known For
Our signature creation that started it all
Cheesecake on a Stick
Our most famous creation—premium cheesecake, perfectly portioned, hand dipped in melted milk chocolate with customized candy toppings. It's portable, shareable, and absolutely irresistible.
Handcrafted Daily: Made fresh with premium ingredients
Dipped to Perfection: Rich chocolate coatings in multiple flavors
Rotating Flavors: Seasonal specials and limited editions
What Our Customers Are Saying
Melissa B.
“Had to try NY cheesecake so decided to come to this hole in the wall. Wasn't disappointed it was so YUMMY!! they were super friendly and accommodating as well. 5/5 first time in NY and will come back here again.”
Marcelle M.
“Absolutely incredible! The cheesecake on a stick is unlike anything I've ever had. Perfectly portioned, rich, and the chocolate coating is spot on. So glad I found this gem in Smithtown!”
Grishma P.
“This place is the perfect go to for sweet spot! Various flavors & the staff was super friendly and helped guide to the perfect pick. Would highly recommend this while in the area!”